User talk:Luigifan18

From Binding of Isaac: Rebirth Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search

About Dark Judas & Vandalism[edit source]

Hi, your contributions are welcome. First and foremost, if you have to revert vandalism, don't edit the page like you did here because it only creates confusion and when reverting the vandal edit you forgot to recover some of the information he deleted. Just use the "undo" button you can see next to his ip address on the history.

About Judas, that you are "fairly sure" is not enough. We need proof and keep speculation away from the wiki, or otherwise this would be a complete mess. AFAIK, (and I tested it myself today) Dark Judas unlocks completion marks but not item or achievements. If you can provide additional info or proof it's not working like that, or you unlocked achievements with Dark Judas, then it's probably a bug. But using Okham Razor meanwhile, it was probably a bad contribution that spreed across the wiki without anyone certificating it). This is only for Dark Judas, not for Undead Lazarus, who it's proven that unlocks achievement for Lazarus (like Ankh does for ???)
GryphusR (talk) 18:58, 17 December 2014 (UTC)

To back this up, it has been proven multiple times that Dark Judas does not unlock his items but does give him the marks. Whether this is a bug is up in the air and would best be discussed in the talk page for known issues. --RoshanLynch (Jsmooth13) (talk) 20:12, 17 December 2014 (UTC)